Old Man Miller goes out for a quiet steak - but does it cut the mustard?

Even before I arrive, there’s an inkling that the Cut and Craft might not be for me. 

It’s an image on Instagram, or more accurately its accompanying caption, that does it. The picture, an attractive slab of tomahawk steak cooked medium-rare, sliced on the angle, and flanked by two halves of a well-grilled tomato, is sound enough.

Perhaps a gold-coated steak is, especially right now, just a bit daft and unnecessary

However, the grimace-inducing caption beneath the tile - “Ladies, the way to his heart,” - makes me feel a little icky. 

In all its pomp and plushness, the Cut and Craft has landed from its origins up the road in York. Clumsy captioning aside, it must be doing something right because the only time I can bag one of its many tables on a Friday is too late to be lunch and too early to be dinner. It is a meal of false starts and half-kept promises.

Interior Of The Cut And Craft In Leeds
The lavish interior at The Cut & Craft Image: Confidentials
Flatiron Steak At The Cut And Craft In Leeds
Does twelve quid for a flat iron really cut it? Image: Confidentials

The ‘Cut’, as you may have gathered, refers to the broad array of cooked beast that the restaurant specialises in. Steak plays a leading role, and in these challenging times, it’s perhaps reassuring to know that you can flatten a flat iron here for the inviting price of twelve quid. It’s a decent if unremarkable piece of meat, lacking in smoky char or the offal-like hum one usually associates with this cut. Hats off for the pricing, though.

Perhaps the version coated in gold leaf, which is apparently a thing, might pack a little more punch. Or perhaps a gold-coated steak is, especially right now, just a bit daft and unnecessary. 

Seabass At The Cut And Craft In Leeds
Sea bass - a firm favourite Image: Confidentials
Cauliflower Cheese At The Cut And Craft In Leeds
Bang-average, I shot you down Image: Confidentials

There are “craft” burgers to get at too, or in my case a generous pile of roasted sea bass (£19.95). And the fish is good - crisp-skinned and firm. However, the small tower of dauphinoise it arrives with is tepid, woolly, and past its best. The luminous pool of saffron sauce promises much but delivers little. 

A bowl of crackly, salty chips (£4.50) goes a way to providing some redemption, as a bowl of chips usually will. Other sides include tired and drooping French beans with shallots and peas (£5), and a truffle cauliflower cheese (£4.50) that has the off-putting top note of a bang-average oil. 

Mussels At The Cut And Craft In Leeds
"Skilfully steamed" mussels Image: Confidentials
Beetroot And Goats Cheese At The Cut And Craft In Leeds
Hey old-timer, its your time to shine Image: Confidentials

It’s not all about the meat, and a heaped bucket of clattering mussels (£9.95) brings with it the promising scent of the seaside. It is, in fairness, a mountain of molluscs that have been skilfully steamed, but the “crusty bread” with which to dredge through a sharp, creamy sauce is erring on stale. 

Similarly, a spin on that old-timer of beetroot and goats cheese (£8.50) starts off well enough but, thanks to a sickly sweet marinade, soon becomes a claggy chore. 

French Beans At The Cut And Craft In Leeds
French beans make the side show Image: Confidentials
Chips At The Cut And Craft In Leeds
Redemptive chips Image: Confidentials

The “Craft” element alludes to the booze, from which feel free to make your maverick selection from the likes of Peroni, Corona or Black Sheep. I have nothing against any of these – I know, I know - though even I can recognise that “craft” is doing a lot of heavy lifting here.

Bottles of wine start in the early £20s, and even though I politely point out that we’ll be fine to pour our own, several members of the team take it upon themselves to do the honours anyway as they float on by. They’ll be under orders, of course, yet it rankles. 

Perhaps if the dishes had been executed with a little more elan I’d be more inclined to enjoy my vast, impressive surroundings. There are deep tan banquettes, a sprawling staircase and a handsome half-moon bar behind which mixologists will do you a Pornstar Martini flight board for twelve quid.

Bar At The Cut And Craft In Leeds
The handsome bar at Cut & Craft, Leeds Image: Confidentials

I wonder if the balance sheet for the fit-out necessitates the inclusion of that gold-smothered steak on the menu. 

It is a shiny and solid space, where the presence of a doorman and a DJ makes The Cut and Craft feel more like a nightclub than a restaurant. Some folk will love it, evidently many already do, but it’s only about 6pm when the volume creeps up, the lights fade down, and Old Man Miller has seen enough.

The Cut and Craft 23 King Edward Street, LS1 6AX

Follow Richard on Twitter @eatingthenorth

Receipt At The Cut And Craft In Leeds
  • Food 7/10

    Mussels 8, beetroot 6, steak 7, seabass 7.5, chips 8, beans 6, cauliflower cheese 6

  • Service 2.5/5

    Less could be more.

  • Atmosphere 2.5/5

    Big night out, food on the side.