Where this time? The Pheasant, 20 Moss Lane, Hightown, L38 3RA. Tel. 0151 929 2106. Web www.thepheasanthightown.co.uk

Pork was succulent and well-cooked, with a separate crackling as brittle as a Tory conference pledge

What’s the story? A “traditional pub and restaurant in the peaceful village of Hightown”, The Pheasant promises “freshly cooked food” with “a hint of Northern style”, whatever that is. Cooking has not always been its strong point, but good reports of late sent us off full of hope and empty of stomach

Location, location, location? Look, I heard you the first time. As it happens, it’s handily placed, on the back road into Hightown from Crosby – or Hightown bends, if you’re local – and a stone’s throw from the Formby bypass, all of which may explain why it never seems to suffer.

What’s the appeal?
For many, it’s the nearest thing to a country pub without emptying your wallet into the petrol tank. Far enough from the bypass to drown out the Formby commute, close enough for a convenient fuel-stop. With green fields and country lanes, it could be the Yorkshire Dales. Except not.

Its sprawling, whitewashed presence seems to have been around forever but clearly hasn’t. Inside low ceilings and lovely old stone flags give way to identikit rustic pub chain style with carpets, lumps of tree and the occasional quirky lamp.

Who goes there?  If the contents of the car park are to judge by – 4x4s, BMWs, Mercs – not a lot of peasants get in the Pheasant. Families, couples, groups of friends, ages ranging from nursery school to nursing home.

Doing a brisk trade, then? Wouldn’t say brisk, exactly. Service took long enough to provoke drumming of fingers and staring into space, not quite long enough to feel you can complain. By the time the family at the next table were served the younger lad was dozing off with his head on his mother’s arm.

Garlic pizetteGarlic pizette

What’s on the table? Roast beef (£14.50), roast pork (£10.95). roast lamb (£15.95), roast chicken (£10.95) and a trio of roasts on one plate (chicken, pork, beef, £14.50)

What about the pheasant? No pheasant, but all come with roast potatoes, Yorkshire pudding, veg, roasted red onion and assorted trimmings.

And if you consider meat to be an abomination? Then it’s a fig and dolcelatte nut roast (£10.95) for you.

Ready to start, are we? We are. They’re not. When it does come, the rocket atop the garlic pizzette (£4.95) has wilted more than the young man at the next table. The thin and crispy baked round of dough is parched and largely devoid of garlic (4/10), alongside a bowl of decent, fleshy, bright green, stone-in Nocellara olives (£2.95, 6/10).  

Dinner is served. Eventually

Beef: Two slices of roast striploin, seasoned with coarse grain mustard, tender, tasty, cooked pink in the middle (7.5/10).

The Trio: A huge chicken supreme (7/10) – breast plus wing bone – crisp of skin and moist of flesh, dominated the plate. Pork, one slice (7/10) was succulent and well-cooked, with a separate crackling as brittle as a Tory conference pledge; plus one slice of the beef.

Nut roastNut roast

Nut roast: A thoughtfully constructed dish with enough tones and interesting textures to keep the tastebuds keen. (7/10)

Lamb: A generous portion of fat gave thickly cut rump its sweetly pleasing flavour. Winner of the dinners (8/10).

Spuds-u-like? Potaotes are roasted in goose fat, according to the menu, though we wouldn’t have guessed. Dense, tired and devoid of crunch. (3.5/10)

Yorkshire pud: A great Yorkshire pudding must come sizzling and glistening, straight from a blistering oven. These specimens appeared to have been hanging round longer than us. Big on quantity, low on quality (4/10). 

Roast trioRoast trio

The gravy: A generous pool or, in the case of the trio and nut roasts, in its own little jug, the latter with added onion. Dark, the density of single cream, decently robust, it won’t win any rosettes but did the job (5/10).

The veg: "Honey roasted” carrot batons had an oddly uneven texture, a mound of white cabbage lacked due care and attention, roasted red onion could have done with a little more caramelising (3.5/10).

The rest: Lemon and thyme stuffing enlivened with bacon bits (7/10) came with all except, thank goodness, the nut roast which was accompanied by a rather plain roasted half of Bramley apple (3/10).

Happy ever afters? The House Sharer (£10.95) is basically an assemblage of various desserts from the list: baked New York style cheesecake is unspectacular but far from offensive; a well-made brownie had a high squidge factor; a citrus-packed lemon tart; and, best of all, a wodge of bourbon ice cream sandwiched between two home-baked cacao-laden cookies (7.5/10).

That’s quite a plateful  Actually it was served on a black floor tile, which, like everything else, took a little too long to arrive. Still, better slate than never. 


Something to wash it down? It’s not exactly staggering distance home – to anywhere – from here, and a wobbly cycle around the bends on a dark night will at best end in a muddy ditch, at best under the wheels of a 4x4/BMW/Merc. Hence the full car park and extensive soft drinks list, including cherry and hibiscus fizz and an alcohol-light (0.5%), politically-charged Brewdog Nanny State. 

What about the non-driver? Not me, you mean? For her, a “perfect” pint of Sharp's Atlantic IPA (£3.45 )and a glass of reed-thin Cooper's Select Tempranillo Cabernet (£5.10)

Do say: Pass the mint sauce.

Don’t say: I'm not a pheasant plucker, I'm a pheasant plucker's son – unless you’re sticking to the lemonade.

Verdict: A long and winding roast on a long and winding road. 

All scored Confidential reviews are paid for by the company, never the restaurant or a PR outfit. Critics dine unannounced and their opinions are completely independent of any commercial relationships. 
The Pheasant, 20 Moss Lane, Hightown, L38 3RA. Tel. 0151 929 2106. Website

Overall score 12/20 (Food: 6/10; Atmosphere 3/5; Service 3/5)
Venues are rated against the best examples of their kind: gastropubs against the best gastropubs, takeaways against the best takeaways, etc. On this basis, the scores represent...

1-5:     Straight into the dog's bowl
6-9:     Netflix and chill
10-11:  In an emergency
12-13:  If you happen to be passing
14-15:  Worth a trip out
16-17:  Very good to exceptional
18-20:  As good as it gets